Many people claim they have a choice for white or yellow cheese once it concerns cheddar or American. However have you ever stopped come think around why they"re two various colors?

The cows absolutely aren"t yellow, and also the cheese seem to taste equally as sharp no issue what hue they occur to be. So what"s the scientific research behind this duality in the deli case?

To brush up on our knowledge of cheese, Food got to out come Zoey Sachs, educational director in ~ Bedford Cheese Shop in new York City, to uncover out why is cheddar usually obtainable in two various hues.

You are watching: Difference between white and yellow american cheese

It transforms out, the difference is all about some dye.


"Some (cheese producers) obstacle annatto seeds on the cheese," Sachs said Due to the fact that milk from various cows deserve to vary contempt in color, some dairies dye their cheese come ensure a more uniformly colored finish product.

If friend think one form of cheese simply tastes better, that"s likely just your mind playing games, according to Sachs. "As far as I"m concerned, the doesn"t include any flavor," she said.

Anatto, follow to the Wisconsin facility for dairy Research, is just one of the earliest dyes recognized to humans. Originally provided by the Aztecs for a range of things consisting of body paint, annatto is one extract native a shrub referred to as achiote and it"s get an impression in Bolivia, Brazil, Columbia, Dominican Republic, Ecuador, Guyana, India, the Philippines, Jamaica, Mexico, Peru, Kenya and also Surinam., that is sourced primarily from south America.


Annatto started being supplied widely in the dairy industry about 150 years ago to give certain cheeses a an ext desirable look, specifically when they needed to be transported and also preserved for much longer periods that time. White cheese often tends to display imperfections an ext readily and also as consumers got an ext used to yellow-orange cheese, it became an supposed option., countless cheddars space yellow. While many cheesemakers usage annatto, some use an fabricated coloring certified dealer instead, according to Sachs. The best means to know precisely what you"re eat is to check the nutrition label. Part producers, prefer Kraft, also include paprika, i m sorry imparts a deeper yellow color.


Since annatto is a organic additive that doesn"t influence the flavor, the choice is really as much as one"s an individual preference. Picking the finest quality cheese, Sachs said, doesn"t need to do through the color, but rather wherein it was produced, exactly how long it to be aged and also where the client buys the from.

How cheese is packaged affect the flavor much more than its color.

"At supermarkets, a many cheddars and also cheeses room wrapped in plastic, which in reality suffocates (them) and also takes away from the flavor," Sachs said


To gain the ideal tasting cheese, Sachs recommended buying that from the glass instance at any type of market or grocery store, fairly than choose up the pre-cut stuff from the dairy aisle. The cheeses that sit in the case, open and unwrapped, room usually of a much better quality. At home, pack the cheese in paper or a towel will also keep it tastier longer.

If you"re supplied to pre-packaged cheeses (as countless of united state are), it"s totally fine come skip the sharp stuff in donate of a milder and also creamier product.

See more: What Kind Of Paint Can I Use On Styrofoam (2021 Review), Top 8 Best Paint For Styrofoam (2021 Review)

Erica Chayes Wida
Erica Chayes Wida is an award-winning journalist, food writer and recipe editor who helmed a neighborhood newspaper before joining"s freelance team. A mommy of two, she loves singing, collecting old vinyl and, of course, cooking. Erica is forever ~ above a global quest to uncover the finest ham and also cheese croissant and brainstorms best over a sauce pot of bubbling pasta sauce. She work has actually been featured top top BBC Travel, Saveur, Martha Stewart Living and PopSugar. Follow along on Instagram.