Listen: ns am a certain believer that we all got this one wrong for ages! because I've been presented to Romeo & Juliet in ~ middleschool i refuse to think that it wasn't intended as a comedy. Shakespeare was known to it is in up for shenanigans. I think the calling this a tragedy was part of the joke. I mean - two teenagers trying to kill themselves but failing? The timing? The lines? This is optimal dark humour. Specifically the means plays to be performed earlier then. Too many of usual folk watching. I don't think it was met through a deep feeling of awe or something. Ns think it's every a big joke that acquired out that hand.

You are watching: Is romeo and juliet a comedy


6 comments
share
save
hide
report
80% Upvoted
Log in or authorize up to leaving a comment
Log InSign Up
Sort by: best


*

level 1
· 7m
Oh, that hilarious. That’s simply not what “comedy” means in the paper definition of his plays. Comedy, essentially, means that the target of the pat is to pair the personalities off in marriage and suggest toward futurity. Tragedy is the opposite: personalities rushing to die by the finish of the play leaving things desolate. Tragedy can absolutely be funny, but it can’t end happily. Comedy doesn’t need to be funny, but there far better at the very least be the promise of marital relationships to come


11
Reply
Share
ReportSave
level 1
· 7m

Well, it's structured exactly like a comedy till the halfway point! however that's excellent to do the tragic components hit harder. He most likely wrote that the very same year as A Midsummer Night's Dream, which has actually the very same star-crossed lovers beginning and even includes an extensive Romeo and also Juliet parody in ~ the end. Ns think it's like he's saying that the line between things walk well and things going terribly is incredibly thin and also up come chance. He'd say together much later on in Hamlet: "Grief joys, happiness grieves on slim accident."


5
Reply
Share
ReportSave
level 1
· 7m · edited 7m

I average - two teenagers trying to death themselves yet failing?

Failing? due to the fact that they're uncovered together dead in the tomb, exactly how do friend think they die?

The only way I have the right to see this is the you're introduce to the fact that the actors don't finish up dead. Yet in the case, Macbeth is really a comedy since they don't actually reduced the command actor's head off.

The last couplet is pretty critical on whether the beat is a comedy.


3
Reply
Share
ReportSave
level 2
· 1m

I think they meant failing in the feeling that they killed themselves because that a incorrect cause. It to be a misunderstanding essentially, so thus a failure.


1
Reply
Share
ReportSave
level 1
· 7m

It's a tragedy the is additionally a critique that the tropes the the comedy genre.

It's not just that it is structured prefer a comedy up until Mercutio is killed however that the too many convoluted plans that the Nurse and Friar Lawrence cook up would certainly actually occupational if the human being of Verona activate by the rule of comedy.


1
Reply
Share
ReportSave
level 1
· 7m · edited 7m

Romeo and Juliet absolutely has many humor. This is the case for plenty of of his tragedies, e.g. Hamlet is yes, really hilarious. Maybe Hamlet has an ext funny quips than many of the comedies.

Tragedy go not average unfunny, or at the very least it didn't in Shakespeare's time. Basically "tragedy" intended that the story ended negative for the main character, i beg your pardon is absolutely the instance for Romeo and also Juliet. And it is famous that misfortune is a an excellent source of dark humor.

"Comedy" on the other hand did not necessarily mean funny. For example the "Divine Comedy" by Dante is quite serious and also somber (although it does have actually fun parts), yet it is designated a "Comedy" because the main character starts out in a bad place (hell) and and finish up in a much better place (heaven).

I median - two adolescents trying to death themselves yet failing?

I think you have misunderstood this component of the story. They do kill themselves.

See more: What Is The Freezing Point Of Lauric Acid Was Measured, Lauric Acid


1
Reply
Share
ReportSave
*

r/shakespeare
Welcome come yellowcomic.com's premier shakespearean subyellowcomic.com! here we can comment on the Bard, his greatness, his works and his life! A community for Shakespeare enthusiasm the civilization over, no issue your age, language, or experience level. From scholastic takes on iambic pentameter to picking out the dirty jokes, there's always space for you here.
36.8k

Members


25

Online


Created Apr 20, 2010
Join
helpyellowcomic.com coinsyellowcomic.com premiumyellowcomic.com gifts
aboutcareerspressadvertiseblogTermsContent policyPrivacy policyMod policy
Back to Top